The Battle of Dunkeswell Down 1488 - The DWG 2014 Xmas Game

This is a DWG - Deus Vult Production of the Battle of Dunkeswell Down 1488

A gathering of the hosts, with the nibbles out and the vanguards of both armies set up

Every now and then we like to go large at the Devon Wargames Group, and our end of year Xmas game always seems to be a good excuse for the club to come together in one game and get all the toys out on the table.

These kind of games are played in a very light hearted spirit, especially at this time of year, and as your humble game reporter, I am often left to come up with a title and background to our clash of arms.

A few last minute conversations before bringing the rest of the forces to the table

So to set the scene, following his victory at Bosworth, King Henry has only reigned for just over two years when he was killed in a hunting accident. All that inbreeding within Royalty finally took its toll as it is rumoured he tried to reload his crossbow the wrong way round with the bolt pointing towards him and well, you know!!

Lancastrian mercenaries

With the unexpected death of Henry Tudor, the whole country braced itself for another round of blood letting to decide who would be King and so it was that two new "wannabe's" emerged from the Houses of York and Lancaster the Duke of Exeter and the Earl of Torbay, cousins from different strands of the Plantagenet line, going back to a common ancestor, the love child of Edward III (1312-1377) and a certain barmaid who worked in the Rose & Crown in Honiton where Edward had his lodgings on a trip to Exeter to cut the ribbon on the new bridge liking the City to St Thomas's.

Archers to the fore with one of Warwick's battles in support

Fact is often stranger than fiction, but it turns out that these two families are still in Devon today and both Andy and Nathan were able to represent them in our game being distant relatives of the two nobles in question and Edward and the Inn keepers daughter. This also explains the unusual DNA discovered in King Richard III's bone analysis earlier this year. Andy and Nathan are involved in the search for Richard's relatives and have both had mouth swab cell samples taken last month.

Loose and darken the sky

So to the clash that nearly re-wrote the history books on the Wars of the Roses. A few notes first will help the reader get a sense of the dynamics at play in this titanic struggle in the Blackdown Hills on the Somerset/Devon border.

First, this battle involved a lot of cousins and close neighbours and the inevitable blood feuds had sprung up during the long years of war. In our re-fight any opposing nobles engaged in fighting units with blood feuds could issue personal combat challenges to decide the fates of the forces in their battle. This was a rule that got used a lot in our game and quite a few old scores were settled and several nobles ended their days as foot stools in their nemesis's campaign tent. In addition, any enemy nobles defeated gave personal honour in the form of points to the victorious noble along with any enemy units driven from the field of battle.

Second, given the nature of warfare in these troubled times, you could never be really sure who was on which side, rather like what goes on in modern politics today. Thus there were rumours circulating that at least one noble in the other camp was liable to change his colours when the opportunity presented.

Yorkist commanders discuss tactics with Sir Thomas, Lord Exmouth. in his unusual black and white surcoat, with his familiar arms, the white snowman.

With the commanders and their forces set up, the respective leaders constructed their orders of march with the van, centre and rear battles nominated. This would be the order that the various battles would arrive on table or be held off on potential flank ambushes.

First contact, Lancastrian billman face off a Yorkist cavalry attack

With Andy (Baron Blackmore) leading the House of Lancaster and Nathan (Baron Goodyear) for York, the units started to arrive on table and it seemed to groan under the weight of all the metal and a few plastics.

The Yorkists made an aggressive thrust at the opposing van with a charge of massed mounted knights into the opposing billmen and archers. The fighting became confused and bloody and both sides struggled to gain an advantage.

The centre is soon engulfed with Yorkist knights at the tilt

As the struggle between the vans continued, more forces started to appear on either side of the fighting units as the opposing lines advanced to support their neighbours or grab important terrain.

The Lancastrian pretender arrives with his battle array

The Yorkist knights start to gain the ascendancy in the middle of the Lancastrian line

With the fighting close to the centre of the Lancastian line at full tilt, the left flank was surprised by a Yorkist flank march of mounted and foot troops.

surprise, surprise, well I didn't expect that!! - the Yorkist flank attack on the Lancastian left

The Earl of Exmouth is caught in the flank by forces under the command of his Son, Lord Thomas, a blood feud indeed!!

With both armies deployed and battle royal joined in the Lancastian centre and left flank, the Yorkist forces had the upper hand. The fighting was fierce as the Lancastian left deployed their "Darken the skies with arrows" tactic. Yorkist archers were decimated in the arrow storm.

Try not to throw 1, 2 or 3 - Oh dear, how sad, never mind!!

Calls of "Yield" were issued by Yorkist commanders as they sought to enforce their advantage.

The Yorkist mounted knights continued to threaten the centre ground 

Warwick tries to contain the situation in the centre of Lancastian lines. Rumours of his death earlier in the war were greatly exaggerated

Both commanders "girded their loin"s and sent heralds along their respective lines promising wealth and titles for one last push.

Baron Goodyear seen "Girding his Loins" during the battle

Desperate to swing the fight in favour of their respective camp, treachery started to reveal it's dark plan. Sir Stephen of Cardiff, a Devon noble banished to estates in South Wales for unnatural relations and concepts in animal husbandry, revealed his true Yorkist sentiments and added to the woes of the Lancastrian centre. In response, the Sir Lancelot of his Peers, Sir Stephen of Lympstone a man who preferred to do most things on the back of a horse suddenly announced, after gutting the Lancastrian centre with his "mounted joustabouts" that he really was for Lancaster and hoped for a spirit of forgive and forget to prevail.

The bloody battle rages between father and son as the Lords of Exmouth engage in mortal combat

The stress of the consequences of failure were starting to tell, or perhaps it was the desire to get down the pub for a Xmas tipple, either way, the personal challenges started to fly. It started with the most personal of blood feuds as Sir Jon, Baron of Exmouth, fuming with rage at the disloyalty of his son, The Honourable Sir Thomas, issued a personal challenge and, although chastising the errant lad with a breath taking display of swordsmanship, left the lad standing and returned to the cheers of his followers. This was to prove a mistake as Sir Thomas, boiling with rage led his men in a fanatical charge breaking two of his fathers units and capturing the old man.

Arrows were flying in all directions

The Lancastian left in trouble

Lancastrian billmen head towards the left flank in a bid to hold it

The day started to lose the light as the fighting broke down into personal little fights all along the line. No quarter was asked or given, noble footstools were being fashioned throughout the opposing camps as personal challenges were decided.

With the battle very much in the hands of the Yorkists, Baron Blackmore decided to make one last desperate roll of the dice. He issued a personal challenge to his opposing contender. Sir Nathan, Baron Goodyear, Lord of the Isles, Protector of the Faith and Lord High Commander of the King's Chamber Pot. The Baron Goodyear, never known to back down from a challenge to his honour, said "no thanks, not when I'm winning and about to get the job of being King".

In the face of such implacable determination, the Lancastrian forces broke contact as darkness fell, quitting the field and headed off towards the rallying point at the Queen's Head.

Warwicks retinue charge into the fight

The day was for York and the honour went to a young noble Sir Thomas of Exmouth who bagged double points for taking his Dad prisoner in a blood feud and breaking two of the enemy units.

Baron Goodyear ignores the catcalls about being frit and prepares to acknowledge the accolade for his victory 

Baron Blackmore, fumes as his personal challenge is refused

So as the dust settled and the armies returned to their camps, it was left to the camp followers to pick over the debris of battle. Their resources had been pillaged by the two opposing sides and their winter supplies entirely consumed as the two forces engaged in this mighty struggle to be known as the Battle of Dunkeswell Down.

It's true, "an army marches on it's stomach"

And what became of the two pretenders to the crown? I hear you ask. Well Baron Blackmore fled to France dying two years later in poverty and madness after his defeat but instilling a burning fire for revenge in his young son who returned to the westcountry, but lost his titles in a game of dominoes, trying to raise funds for a new campaign.

The victor of this tale also suffered an ignoble end failing to get back to Westminster for his Coronation after picking up a dose of the pox after a night out in Exeter to celebrate his recent victory. The rest as they say, is history.

Let the ballads say that much fun was had at the DWG 2014 Xmas game, with much laughter and banter prevailing. Thanks to Gamemeister Chas for pulling the scenario together and managing to herd cats.

Happy Xmas to all and here's looking forward to new games in 2015

Deus Vult - First Play

Report by Steve H, Pictures by JJ
Every summer we all put on our best smocks and head north to Barnstaple for the great Summer game . This involves much planning and preparation as we never seem to choose a period for which we already have masses of figures and this year will be no exception as we will be playing a big Crusader game (or whatever we are supposed to call this period now).

So the following activities need to be started in advance:

Buy and paint additional figures on top of any existing stock.

Parcel out painting duties

Learn the relevant rule set.

Get false birth certificates made up to prove that we are all related and this will prevent us being burnt in a wicker frame as outsiders.

Buy beer.

A smaller advance game is also played to try out the said new rules so that we all have plenty of time to forget it all before the big event takes place in June/July.

This month Chas bravely put on the trial game using the Deus Vult rules which are aimed at this period. There is no point giving a Battle Report as it was just a trial game where we tried to play out every rule going irrespective of its effect on the battle and also because I got completely wiped out . If you want to know about sequences and stuff then there have been much more complete reviews for Deus Vult on other sites like TMP which I suggest you read. Instead this is going to be a gamers’ first glance. What you get below is my summary of what we learned from the game, intermixed with pictures of the game taken by JJ.

You start by splitting your forces into Divisions, we had five each with four to six units per division and the divisional commanders have various ratings which are rolled for against a table, recorded onto their individual card and these are used as required. 

Each unit also has all the normal stuff you would expect as well, all be it with different names. Discipline is used for movement decisions and Courage for morale (overly simplified by me) but you can on occasions use your Divisional Commanders ratings instead if within the 8” radius.

Then you decide each turn who has the Initiative (Straight roll off) and you stack your Leader Cards in the sequence you wish to move them, each side then moves one division (Initiative Winner decides which side gets to move first) and carries out all shooting and fighting before moving on to the next. 

What did I learn, well obviously not much given my complete lack of survivors but here goes.

Commanders have a Command rating either rolled for as above or historically allocated and this determines how many units in your division you can choose to move each turn. 

Suppose like our reserve your command rating is one and you have four units , well each turn one unit can take actions as normal and you join a second unit for the old follow me type stunt. The other two units must then wait until everyone else has moved and either do nothing, or roll against their Discipline rating to activate.

Now I wish at this point  to add in a common occurrence. Whenever you have to do something like a Discipline Test or Morale/Courage you get to do the 4+ roll . As long as you can score 4+ on a dice you pass, I like this as its simple, no cross referencing multiple lists. Better troops/leaders get to roll more dice but still only need one 4+. So our elite reserve got to throw two dice to try and activate for being out of command and my scummy ill-disciplined horse archers only had one roll which is why I failed my evade dice three times running. 

Ah ha you say, why not use your commanders rating instead, that’s all very well but he was also a one and besides he was underneath piles of dead horse archers.

Failure is punished by going into disorder so think before you roll.

Shooting is ok as well, ranges are quite long but suitable for 28mm and you get two dice per six man infantry base and one dice per two man cavalry base. 6’s are killing hits with 4’s and 5’s being what I call morale hits. First try and save the kills against your armour save and then add all the hits together to see if you have forced a morale/courage roll (the old 4+ again). Usually anything between three to five hits will be enough depending on the troops. You can shoot twice if standing still.

Now hand to hand. This took me a while to absorb, the main point is that you don’t get to fight back until its your turn and this takes a bit of getting used to, plus if they have already moved that division this turn then it is possible, with good luck, to hit them again in the next turn before they get any chance to reply. Hand to hand requires lots of dice. Hits as per shooting above.

Key points I learnt the hard way.

If charged and you have only one dice to roll to try and evade then you might as well counter charge no matter how puny you are .

You see we are now moving on to Disorder, this is heavily punished in Deus Vult.

Never get disordered. If you fail a 4+ roll then you are disordered (there are other ways but that’s the main one). If disordered then all shooting and combat dice are now changed so that a  4/5/6 will kill. Nasty!

In our game a unit of half dead knights, (that’s half dead not undead) being rather miffed about the amount of pointy things coming their way, charged all those responsible and each time my horse archer units got charged they failed the evade roll, becoming disordered and got to lie down in untidy heaps very fast. 

I admit that if I had instead counter charged I would still have had to pass a Disarray test but without the rules I don’t remember if this was as bad. Probably.

Finally each unit has a mass of additional skills like Counter Charge or Manoeuvrable , I think the record for one of our units was nine and these all do various jolly things to liven up the day.

So don’t get disordered, and finish off those weak units (taken off when you lose the next base after 50% e.g. if six bases strong then remove from table when down to two bases).

Obviously it was our first time so we must have made masses of errors, however we did try out as many rules as possible and it looks a promising set of rules suitable for the Summer Game.